• Home
  • News
    • BREAKING!
    • Investigation
    • Media
    • Interview
    • NEWS ANALYSIS
    • PRESS RELEASE
  • Politics
  • Business
    • OIL & GAS
    • AVIATION
    • ENERGY
    • ECONOMY
    • Agriculture
  • Crime
  • Entertainment
    • MUSIC&ENTERTAINMENT
    • PEOPLE/SOCIETY/CELEBRATION
  • Sports
  • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Mission Statement
  • More
    • INTERNATIONAL
      • AFRICA
      • DIPLOMATIC
      • FOREIGN
    • DISASTER
    • Civil Society/Human Rights
    • EDUCATION
    • Health
    • Columnist
    • ENVIRONMENT
    • Workers World
    • Judiciary
    • Guest Column
    • Opinion
    • RELIGION
    • ADVENTURE
    • HISTORY
    • DEFENCE
    • SEXUAL VIOLENCE
    • ICT
    • SUNDAY SERMON
    • OBITUARY
    • FOR THE RECORD
    • REACTION
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending
  • Henry Kissinger: A Curse On Africa, Asia And Latin America; By Owei Lakemfa
  • Benue Teachers Demand Implementation Of N30,000 Minimum Wage, Pay Monthly Salaries On 25th
  • Prof Jinadu And The Struggle Against Beaching Electoral Democracy; By Jibrin Ibrahim
  • 40 Speakers For Amplify In-depth Media Conference As 11 Finalists Picked For 18th WSAIR In Abuja Weekend
  • Veteran Trade Union Activist, Frank Kokori, Bows Out At 80
  • Group Demands Relocation Of Kogi Governorship Elections Tribunal From Lokoja
  • Abuja One-Chance Victim Not Abandoned By Hospital, Says Wike’s Panel
  • Despite Economic Difficulties, It’s Unthinkable To Postpone Our Conference – NASU President
Facebook Twitter Instagram
National RecordNational Record
  • Home
  • News
    1. BREAKING!
    2. Investigation
    3. Media
    4. Interview
    5. NEWS ANALYSIS
    6. PRESS RELEASE
    Featured

    Benue Teachers Demand Implementation Of N30,000 Minimum Wage, Pay Monthly Salaries On 25th

    By National RecordDecember 8, 20230
    Recent

    Benue Teachers Demand Implementation Of N30,000 Minimum Wage, Pay Monthly Salaries On 25th

    December 8, 2023

    40 Speakers For Amplify In-depth Media Conference As 11 Finalists Picked For 18th WSAIR In Abuja Weekend

    December 7, 2023

    Veteran Trade Union Activist, Frank Kokori, Bows Out At 80

    December 7, 2023
  • Politics
    Featured

    Group Demands Relocation Of Kogi Governorship Elections Tribunal From Lokoja

    By National RecordDecember 7, 20230
    Recent

    Group Demands Relocation Of Kogi Governorship Elections Tribunal From Lokoja

    December 7, 2023

    Benue APC Crisis: SWC Halts Meeting to Suspend Chairman

    December 6, 2023

    Forum Of APC LG Chairpersons Kicks Against Alia’s Appointed LG Caretaker Committees

    December 2, 2023
  • Business
    1. OIL & GAS
    2. AVIATION
    3. ENERGY
    4. ECONOMY
    5. Agriculture
    Featured

    NNPC To Work With Partners To Reduce Methane Emissions, Says Eyesan

    By National RecordDecember 6, 20230
    Recent

    NNPC To Work With Partners To Reduce Methane Emissions, Says Eyesan

    December 6, 2023

    At COP28 In Dubai, NNPC Ltd Seals LNG Deals For Domestic, International Markets

    December 6, 2023

    AfDB’s Investments In Nigeria Hits $4bn, Says Official

    October 27, 2023
  • Crime
    Featured

    Abuja One-Chance Victim Not Abandoned By Hospital, Says Wike’s Panel

    By National RecordDecember 7, 20230
    Recent

    Abuja One-Chance Victim Not Abandoned By Hospital, Says Wike’s Panel

    December 7, 2023

    Benue Police Nab 18 Suspects Over Alleged Abduction

    November 28, 2023

    Alia’s Aide Cautions Youth On False Alarm Following Mobbing Of Lecturer Over Alleged Penis ‘Snatching’

    November 9, 2023
  • Entertainment
    1. MUSIC&ENTERTAINMENT
    2. PEOPLE/SOCIETY/CELEBRATION
    Featured

    Fifty Years On, Bruce Lee’s Legacy Squares Up to Modern Life in Hong Kong

    By National RecordJuly 18, 20230
    Recent

    Fifty Years On, Bruce Lee’s Legacy Squares Up to Modern Life in Hong Kong

    July 18, 2023

    Hollywood’s Striking Actors Join Writers on the Picket Lines

    July 14, 2023

    EU Engages Nigerian Artiste, Influencer to Promote Partnership With Africa

    October 28, 2022
  • Sports
    Featured

    Google Celebrates Yekini’s 60th Birthday With Doodle

    By National RecordOctober 23, 20230
    Recent

    Google Celebrates Yekini’s 60th Birthday With Doodle

    October 23, 2023

    Lobi Stars Suspends Manager, Appoints First Indigenous Head Coach

    October 10, 2023

    Djokovic Eyes No.1 As US Open Gets Underway

    August 28, 2023
  • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Mission Statement
  • More
    • INTERNATIONAL
      • AFRICA
      • DIPLOMATIC
      • FOREIGN
    • DISASTER
    • Civil Society/Human Rights
    • EDUCATION
    • Health
    • Columnist
    • ENVIRONMENT
    • Workers World
    • Judiciary
    • Guest Column
    • Opinion
    • RELIGION
    • ADVENTURE
    • HISTORY
    • DEFENCE
    • SEXUAL VIOLENCE
    • ICT
    • SUNDAY SERMON
    • OBITUARY
    • FOR THE RECORD
    • REACTION
National RecordNational Record
Home»News»FOREIGN»China’s Approach To The War In Gaza Is Not Anti-Israel. It’s Designed To Contain The US; By Ahmed Aboudouh
FOREIGN

China’s Approach To The War In Gaza Is Not Anti-Israel. It’s Designed To Contain The US; By Ahmed Aboudouh

National RecordBy National RecordOctober 27, 2023Updated:October 27, 2023No Comments7 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Reddit WhatsApp Email
Abbas of Palestine and Xi-Jinping of China
Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas shakes hands with China’s President Xi Jinping after a signing ceremony at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing on June 14, 2023. (Photo by Jade Gao - Pool/Getty Images)
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest WhatsApp Email

CHINA’s position on the war in Gaza is controversial and ambiguous to many observers. Beijing has criticized Israel’s blanket bombardment of civilians and condemned violations of international law.

President Xi Jinping waited until after the Third Belt and Road Forum to comment on the crisis, reiterating China’s long-held position that a two-state solution should be implemented and calling for a humanitarian corridor to allow aid into the besieged Gaza Strip.

China has reaffirmed its historical affinity to the Palestinian cause (its policy since the time of Mao Zedong) and its policy of what might be called ‘anti-Western neutrality’ – that is, neutrality that stops short of condemning any country or force that undermines Western centrality in the global order (rather than explicitly lending support to Hamas).

Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi went further, describing Israel’s bombardment of civilians in Gaza as actions that ‘have gone beyond the scope of self-defence’. At the same time, Beijing avoided condemning Hamas’s atrocities against civilians.As in Ukraine, China is positioning itself as a peace-seeking, ‘neutral’ great power, in contrast to the US, whose committed support for Israel is depicted by Beijing as a destabilizing, violent influence in the region.

But China’s comments on the war, and its non-interventionist stance, mean it is unable to influence events – an uncomfortable position when its interests are directly threatened by the war.   

That may be why Beijing is increasingly aligning with Russia on the Palestinian issue, an unprecedented development that aims to guarantee a place at the negotiating table at minimal cost to both – and undermine US influence in the region.

Familiar tactics

It is now clear that China is adopting the Ukraine playbook on the Israel–Hamas war, seeking to publicly chart a different course from the US and its allies and their unconditional support for Israel.

Chinese officials’ diplomatic interactions with the region are strictly adhering to Beijing’s policy of balancing between the Gulf States and Iran and between the regional main powers and Israel.

The rhetoric from Beijing is carefully designed to focus on the broader context, such as implementing the two-state solution, addressing humanitarian issues and preventing the conflict from turning into a regional one.It has refrained from describing the Hamas incursion into Israel as a terrorist attack but has called Israel’s retaliation ‘collective punishment’ of Palestinian civilians – signalling its opposition to an Israeli ground invasion of Gaza.

This is not simply the behaviour of a peace-loving, mercantilist giant. Rather, it is a structured, deliberate strategy to achieve China’s objectives in the region and beyond.

‘Anti-Western neutrality’

China does not aspire to replace the US position in the Middle East, but will undoubtedly be pleased to see the US again drawn into a conflict in the region.

Chinese experts believe the more strategic non-East Asian theatres that require Washington’s attention, the more time and space China gains to assert its strategic domination in the Indo-Pacific.

China has reaffirmed its historical affinity to the Palestinian cause (its policy since the time of Mao Zedong) and its policy of what might be called ‘anti-Western neutrality’ – that is, neutrality that stops short of condemning any country or force that undermines Western centrality in the global order (rather than explicitly lending support to Hamas).China also uses ‘Anti-Western neutrality’ to appeal to a densely populated and strategically important support base. Many Global South nations are sympathetic to Palestine, and the war is therefore an issue China can use to mobilize support for its leadership of developing countries.

By stressing its neutral stance and its role as a voice of the Global South, China wants to check the US’s moral standing and legitimize internationalization of the issue, calling for a global conference to initiate a peace process – thereby removing Washington from its decades-long position as the unchallenged arbiter in the conflict.

This in turn helps win backing for Chinese positions on core issues like Xinjiang and Taiwan – and for Xi’s vision of global governance, enshrined in his signature initiatives: the Global Development Initiative (GDI), the Global Security Initiative (GSI), and the Global Civilization Initiative (GCI).

China has also sought to consolidate regional unity, urging the Islamic World to ‘speak with one voice’ with China on Palestine, building on its initiative to mediate a diplomatic agreement between Saudi Arabia and Iran last March – a big win for the GSI, which is based on regional countries independently taking the lead in ‘resolving regional security issues through solidarity and coordination.’

The war encouraged Saudi Crown Prince Mohamed bin Salaman and Iran’s President Ibrahim Raisi to speak on the phone for the first time, something China was pleased to see.

By stressing its neutral stance and its role as a voice of the Global South, China wants to check the US’s moral standing and legitimize internationalization of the issue, calling for a global conference to initiate a peace process – thereby removing Washington from its decades-long position as the unchallenged arbiter in the conflict.The ultimate objective is to degrade the US’s global standing and win the ‘discourse power’ war by capitalizing on sympathy for Palestinians worldwide.

A flawed policy

However, beyond the short term, China’s policy is flawed and unsustainable.

China has significant economic connections to the region. It is the biggest trading partner with most MENA countries and almost half of its imported oil comes from the Gulf. China’s overall trade with the Arab world stood at more than $430 billion last year.

While the Biden administration has failed to speak in a balanced way on the war, instead unconditionally supporting Israel, it has mobilized US diplomatic might to influence Israel’s response – preventing the conflict from spreading outside Gaza and allowing aid to reach civilians.

Its committed response to the war, in fact, may put to bed the idea that Washington has departed from the Middle East, strengthening its traditional regional role.

Chinese ‘anti-Western neutrality’ meanwhile, has led Israel to retaliate diplomatically by joining the UK and 50 other countries at the UN to condemn China’s policies against the Uyghurs in Xinjiang, saying they constitute ‘international crimes, in particular, crimes against humanity.’

Like the Ukraine war, the Israel–Hamas war shows that ambiguity and ‘anti-Western neutrality’ are complex acts. To be considered neutral, others must also believe it.  

Neutrality also prevents China from directly influencing these dangerous events in a way that favours its interests.

China has significant economic connections to the region. It is the biggest trading partner with most MENA countries and almost half of its imported oil comes from the Gulf. China’s overall trade with the Arab world stood at more than $430 billion last year.  

These significant interests are vulnerable to regional wars and instability – but Chinese leaders can only watch events unfold from a distance.

China has confined itself to voicing objections and calling for peace. Alignment with Russia may amplify its voice in a peace settlement. But there is a long way to go before that becomes reality. China must understand that in these crucial days, lip service diplomacy is the last thing MENA people want.

China should now understand that transactional de-escalation between regional rivals like Saudi Arabia and Iran does not necessarily constitute peace.

One of the key lessons of the conflict is that Iranian proxies were ready to blow up the region to impede Saudi normalization with Israel. China-sponsored integration initiatives will be no more successful at preventing another similar episode.

Possessing great power capabilities is one thing. Acting like a great power is another. The US has demonstrated its continuing commitment to Israel and ability to influence Israeli policy.

China has confined itself to voicing objections and calling for peace. Alignment with Russia may amplify its voice in a peace settlement. But there is a long way to go before that becomes reality. China must understand that in these crucial days, lip service diplomacy is the last thing MENA people want.

Chatham House.org

Ahmed Aboudouh is Chatham House’s Associate Fellow, Middle East and North Africa Programme

Ahmed Aboudouh China contain Gaza
National Record

Related Posts

A Brief History Of The Journey, Travails And Tribulations Of Edumoga; By Emmanuel Oloja Ejeikwu

December 2, 2023

The International Labor Movement Is Mobilizing For A Free Palestine

November 30, 2023

2024 Budget Foundation Upon Which We Shall Erect The Future Of This Great Nation; By Bola Ahmed Tinubu

November 29, 2023

Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

Recent Posts
  • Henry Kissinger: A Curse On Africa, Asia And Latin America; By Owei Lakemfa
  • Benue Teachers Demand Implementation Of N30,000 Minimum Wage, Pay Monthly Salaries On 25th
  • Prof Jinadu And The Struggle Against Beaching Electoral Democracy; By Jibrin Ibrahim
  • 40 Speakers For Amplify In-depth Media Conference As 11 Finalists Picked For 18th WSAIR In Abuja Weekend
  • Veteran Trade Union Activist, Frank Kokori, Bows Out At 80
About Us
About Us

Contest Communications Limited is a company incorporated to operate a purely ideologically progressive and working class news establishment. Registered in 2019 to bring this idea into reality, National Record, with the domain name: https://nationalrecord.com.ng/ was conceived to operate as an online news publication.

Contact Us

Contest Communications Limited

Address: 2nd Floor, Suite 21B, Dagep Plaza, Opposite Anaconda Garden and Resort, Off Karu Roundabout, Karu-Site, AMAC, Abuja-FCT.

Phone: +2348033209749

Email: Nationalrecordng@gmail.com

Facebook Twitter Instagram Pinterest
© 2023 All Right Reserved. National Record. Designed By DeedsTech.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.