With the 2027 General elections drawing closer, IDUH ONAH x-rays the various scenarios in which the deepening political feud between Governor Hyacinth Alia and his political benefactor, Senator George Akume, is threatening to turn the ruling APC’s formidable electoral advantage into a political liability. The defection of seven former commissioners to the PDP has further heightened tensions, raising the prospect that the opposition could reclaim power not necessarily through its own growing political strength, but by exploiting the deepening divisions within its fiercest rival.
THE POLITICAL battle for Benue State ahead of the 2027 governorship election is assuming a potentially consequential dimension, with Governor Hyacinth Alia facing mounting challenges from within the ruling All Progressives Congress (APC) even as the opposition Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) seeks to turn the divisions to its electoral advantage.
At the centre of the unfolding drama is the increasingly bitter political confrontation between Alia and his estranged political godfather, Senator George Akume, the Secretary to the Government of the Federation (SGF). What initially appeared to be a disagreement between two very close political partners immediately after the 2023 elections over the sharing of the spoils of office quickly evolved into a struggle for control of the APC’s structures. Now, it has transitioned into a full battle for political influence and survival on who controls the mobilisation machinery to capture power in the state.
The latest development to underscore the depth of the crisis is the defection of seven former commissioners who served in Alia’s administration. The former appointees have abandoned the governor’s political camp, aligned with the PDP and declared support for its 2027 governorship candidate, Chief Michael Kaase Aondoakaa, SAN.
Their decision, coming amid the unresolved Alia-Akume confrontation and the emergence of rival political mobilisation platforms in support of President Bola Ahmed Tinubu’s re-election, raises the fundamental question: Could the combination of the APC’s internal crisis and the defection of influential former government officials create the opening through which the PDP could reclaim Benue in 2027?
While it may be too early to predict the outcome of the election, the developments suggest that Alia’s second-term ambition could face a more complicated political contest than the governor’s camp might have anticipated.
There is however the prospect, if assessed realistically, that the political value of these former commissioners may automatically translate to substantial electoral followings. In other words, their ability to mobilise supporters, influence local political structures and deliver votes will determine whether their defection will be an electoral asset for the PDP, else it will remain largely symbolic. Nevertheless, the timing and collective nature of their decision represent an uncomfortable political development for Alia.
The Symbolism of Political Abandonment
The decision by the seven former commissioners to pitch their tents with Aondoakaa is significant for reasons beyond the numerical strength of the defectors. They are not strangers to the political structure that brought Alia to power. They were members of his administration and occupied positions in the State Executive Council, giving them firsthand experience of the government’s political and administrative environment.
The ex-commissioners are Prof. Moses Ogbaji, former Commissioner for Agriculture and Natural Resources; Aondowase Kunde, former Commissioner for Humanitarian Affairs and Disaster Management; Martins Shaagee, former Commissioner for Lands, Survey and Solid Minerals; Anna Itodo, former Commissioner for Women Affairs and Social Welfare; Joyce Luga, former Commissioner for Cooperative, Urban and Rural Development; Omale Omale, former Commissioner for Power, Transport and Renewable Energy; and Matthew Aboh, former Commissioner for Information, Culture and Tourism.
Their decision to support Aondoakaa was announced by Dr Terver Akase, Director of Media and Communications of the Aondoakaa/Ogbenjuwa Campaign Council, in a statement published on his verified Facebook page and subsequently reported by several media organisations.
The former commissioners reportedly expressed confidence in Aondoakaa’s leadership capacity and pledged to mobilise support for his emergence as governor in 2027. For the PDP, this represents a valuable political endorsement that offers the opposition an opportunity to portray Alia’s administration as one gradually losing the confidence of individuals who were once part of its governing structure. It also gives Aondoakaa an opportunity to position himself as a rallying point for aggrieved politicians and stakeholders who believe that Alia failed to sufficiently accommodate their political interests.
More importantly, the defections could encourage other dissatisfied APC members to reconsider their political positions, particularly if the disagreement between Alia and Akume remains unresolved.
There is however the prospect, if assessed realistically, that the political value of these former commissioners may automatically translate to substantial electoral followings. In other words, their ability to mobilise supporters, influence local political structures and deliver votes will determine whether their defection will be an electoral asset for the PDP, else it will remain largely symbolic. Nevertheless, the timing and collective nature of their decision represent an uncomfortable political development for Alia.
Of course, the Benue chapter of the APC has sought to minimise the implications of the defections. The party’s State Publicity Secretary, Benedict Yawe, dismissed the former commissioners’ political relevance, arguing that they had little or no electoral value in their respective wards and local government areas. He also reportedly claimed that the former commissioners were removed from office because of poor performance and incompetence, insisting that their departure would not affect the APC’s electoral fortunes.
The response reflects the ruling party’s determination to prevent the development from becoming a larger narrative of political abandonment. There is an understandable argument in the APC’s position. Former public officeholders do not automatically retain the political influence they enjoyed while in government. Their departure from the administration may not necessarily translate into a corresponding movement of voters.
But the party’s dismissal does not entirely address the larger political question. For seven former members of the State Executive Council to publicly align with an opposition governorship candidate is not an ordinary occurrence. Even if their individual political influence is limited, their collective action will certainly raise questions about the quality of political relationships within the administration.
The more important issue is whether the defections represent isolated grievances or a wider pattern of dissatisfaction that could produce further defections. If the APC is correct that the seven individuals lack political influence, the development may amount to little more than a temporary embarrassment. But if more stakeholders follow their example, the party could discover that it underestimated the extent of disaffection within its ranks.
A Feud That Has Become an Electoral Liability
The bigger political problem confronting Alia, however, is his unresolved confrontation with Akume, who obviously is not an ordinary APC chieftain. He is a former governor of Benue, former senator, former Minister of Special Duties and now the SGF. His longstanding political networks and experience in the state’s political landscape make him a formidable stakeholder whose influence cannot simply be wished away with a narrative that his rift with Alia arose because the governor refused to submit the state’s treasury to his control.
Alia, on the other hand, is the incumbent governor, with the institutional advantages and political resources associated with occupying the highest office in the state. The relationship between the two men was once defined by political mentorship and the alliance that facilitated Alia’s emergence as governor in 2023. Their estrangement has since become one of the defining political developments in Benue.
The disagreement has gone beyond the question of whether Akume should continue to exercise influence over the governor. It now concerns who determines the direction of the APC, who controls its political structures and who enjoys the authority to organise the party’s electoral activities. The parallel APC state congresses held on March 4 provided a clear illustration of the crisis. The Alia-aligned faction returned Benjamin Omale as state chairman, while the Akume-aligned faction affirmed the Austin Agada-led executive committee for another four-year term.
For a ruling party preparing for a major election, this is a dangerous situation. The governorship election will require a coordinated political structure capable of managing nominations, reconciling aggrieved stakeholders, organising campaigns and mobilising voters across the state’s 23 local government areas. A party divided over who controls its own leadership machinery may find it difficult to prosecute an effective campaign, especially when the disagreement involves its sitting governor and a powerful national political figure.
The Depth of the Crisis
Perhaps the most revealing development in the Alia-Akume confrontation is the emergence of the Benue Strategic Alliance for Tinubu-Shettima 2027. The November 13 report by National Record, which drew on News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) reporting, provides an important insight into the changing character of the disagreement.
The alliance, reportedly involving Akume-aligned APC members and politicians from opposition parties, including the PDP and Labour Party, was established ostensibly to mobilise support for President Tinubu and Vice President Shettima ahead the 2027 polls. Its political composition, however, has become a source of controversy.
Prominent opposition figures associated with the arrangement reportedly include ex-Governor Ortom, PDP governorship candidate Aondoakaa and Labour Party governorship candidate Matthias Ibyuan. The association of these opposition figures with an alliance involving members of the APC aligned with Akume is particularly significant because it brings together politicians who would ordinarily be expected to contest against one another in the governorship election. The development prompted an angry reaction from Alia’s political camp.
At a November 13 press conference in Makurdi, Richard Asema, Director-General of the Tinubu-Alia 2027 Campaign Council, accused the alliance of harbouring a hidden agenda to undermine Alia’s re-election while using support for Tinubu as a political cover. Asema specifically mentioned Akume and the Minister of Water Resources and Sanitation, Prof. Joseph Utsev, among the senior political figures associated with the arrangement.
He argued that the composition of the alliance, particularly its inclusion of opposition governorship candidates, made its stated purpose questionable. Asema therefore rejected the alliance, describing it as injurious to the APC’s electoral machinery in Benue. He also disclosed that the APC had already constituted a campaign council comprising more than 900 party leaders and members, inaugurated on November 5 at IBB Square, Makurdi.
According to him, some individuals associated with the rival strategic alliance had initially been appointed to the APC campaign council but subsequently announced that they would not participate in its activities.
This detail is particularly revealing. It suggests that the disagreement is not simply about the establishment of another platform for supporting Tinubu but more about the refusal of some influential party members to operate under the political structure being coordinated by Alia. In other words, the dispute concerns political authority and the governor’s control of the party’s electoral machinery.
Supporting Tinubu Not the Same as Supporting Alia
The response of the strategic alliance adds another important dimension to the controversy. Its Director-General, Akange Audu, rejected the allegation that the organisation was designed to sabotage Alia’s re-election, describing the accusations as political blackmail.
Audu maintained that the alliance was an independent political mobilisation platform established to bring together estranged APC members and politicians from other parties who support Tinubu’s second-term ambition. His most politically significant argument was that supporting Tinubu should not automatically mean supporting Alia. The position is significant because it challenges the governor’s apparent attempt to link the President’s re-election project synonymous with his own political ambition or survival in Benue.
It also exposes a potential contradiction within the APC’s political arrangements. If Akume and his associates are genuinely committed to Tinubu’s re-election, must they operate under a campaign structure controlled by Alia? Conversely, if the alliance includes opposition governorship candidates who intend to defeat the APC in Benue, can its activities be separated entirely from the political interests of those candidates?
Benue’s challenges, particularly insecurity, displacement, agricultural disruption, unemployment, infrastructure deficits and the economic difficulties confronting ordinary residents, offer the opposition important issues around which to build its campaign. Aondoakaa must therefore go beyond demonstrating that he has the backing of politicians dissatisfied with the incumbent to actually convincing voters that he possesses the leadership capacity, political organisation and policy direction required to govern the state.
These are the difficult questions raised by the competing positions.
The alliance also claimed that it had more than 1,000 members drawn from different political groups, including the three senators representing Benue State, 10 members of the House of Representatives and several state legislators. These figures remain the alliance’s claims and should not be mistaken for independently verified membership or a confirmed political commitment by every individual mentioned.
Nevertheless, the reported composition of the alliance is politically important. If the claims about its support base are substantially accurate, it suggests that Akume’s political network retains considerable capacity to mobilise stakeholders independently of the governor’s camp. That possibility is particularly uncomfortable for Alia because it demonstrates that occupying the governorship does not necessarily translate into exclusive control of the APC’s political networks. It also provides the PDP with a potential opening to engage political stakeholders who may not necessarily be prepared to defect formally from the APC but are dissatisfied with the governor’s leadership.
The National Record report, therefore, adds a crucial piece of evidence to the argument that the Alia-Akume feud has become a structural challenge to the APC rather than a disagreement that can be dismissed as a personal quarrel.
Can the APC Neutralise the Crisis?
Despite the mounting disagreements, it would be premature to conclude that the APC has lost its electoral advantage in Benue. Indeed, the governor’s camp has advanced substantial political arguments to support its confidence ahead of 2027.
In defending the party’s position, Asema cited the APC’s performance in the 2023 general election, when it won the governorship, secured two of the state’s three senatorial seats and won 10 of the 11 House of Representatives constituencies.
He further claimed that the APC currently controls 27 of the 32 seats in the Benue State House of Assembly, all 23 local government chairmanship positions and all 276 elected councillorship positions. These figures, if sustained, represent a considerable organisational advantage for the ruling party.
Asema also attributed the governor’s popularity to what he described as achievements in infrastructure development, industrialisation, education, employment and workers’ welfare. He specifically cited the employment of 9,700 teachers, payment of salaries and pensions, and the clearance of outstanding arrears.
These are claims advanced by the governor’s campaign council, and their electoral implications will depend on how voters assess the administration’s actual performance. Nevertheless, they provide an important counter-argument to the suggestion that the APC’s internal disagreements automatically make it vulnerable to defeat. The party still has a strong political presence in a sitting governor and a substantial crust of elected officeholders.
The challenge is whether these advantages can be converted into a cohesive electoral organisation despite the unresolved confrontation between two powerful political camps. The APC may have the numbers, but the question is whether it has the unity required to deploy them effectively.
Aondoakaa’s Opportunity to turn APC’s Divisions Into Votes
For PDP’s Aondoakaa, the unfolding crisis represents an opportunity that could significantly improve his political prospects in Benue. His candidacy offers the PDP a focal point around which aggrieved politicians, former government officials and dissatisfied APC stakeholders can potentially rally.
His emergence as the PDP’s governorship candidate also provides the opposition with an opportunity to challenge the Alia administration on governance, security, economic development and political leadership. His endorsement by the seven ex-commissioners strengthens that effort by allowing the PDP to argue that its candidate is attracting individuals who have firsthand experience of Alia’s administration.
The reported association of Aondoakaa with the strategic alliance for Tinubu’s re-election also makes the political landscape more interesting. It suggests that the PDP candidate may be benefiting from political contacts and conversations that extend beyond the traditional boundaries of his party. However, it is important not to conflate association with the alliance with a formal endorsement of Aondoakaa by Akume. Neither the existence of the alliance nor the presence of opposition politicians within it establishes that Akume has decided to support the PDP candidate for governor.
For the PDP to convert the situation into an electoral breakthrough, it must do more than benefit from the APC’s disagreements. It needs to consolidate its own party structures, reconcile competing interests, attract credible political stakeholders and build a formidable grassroots mobilisation network across the state. It must also present a convincing alternative to Alia’s administration.
Benue’s challenges, particularly insecurity, displacement, agricultural disruption, unemployment, infrastructure deficits and the economic difficulties confronting ordinary residents, offer the opposition important issues around which to build its campaign. Aondoakaa must therefore go beyond demonstrating that he has the backing of politicians dissatisfied with the incumbent to actually convincing voters that he possesses the leadership capacity, political organisation and policy direction required to govern the state.
The irony in al this is that the APC may ultimately lose Benue not necessarily because the PDP has become overwhelmingly stronger, but because the ruling party could become too divided to defend the political advantage it already possesses. Whether that possibility becomes reality will depend largely on what Alia and Akume do next.
The PDP must also guard against becoming merely a temporary refuge for politicians whose immediate motivation is opposition to Alia. A coalition held together principally by resentment against an incumbent can become unstable when the contest for power intensifies.
Three Possible Scenarios Ahead
The unfolding developments suggest three broad possibilities for Benue’s political future.
The first is a negotiated reconciliation between Alia and Akume. If the two camps find common ground, the APC could retain its existing political advantage and enter the election with a stronger organisational structure. Such an arrangement would, however, require concessions and a workable understanding of how power and influence will be shared within the party.
The second is the continuation of the political cold war, with both camps maintaining separate mobilisation structures while publicly claiming loyalty to Tinubu. This scenario could weaken the APC’s campaign, create confusion among party members and encourage further defections to the opposition. It would provide the PDP with an opportunity to consolidate support among aggrieved stakeholders.
The third, and potentially most consequential, is a more decisive political realignment in which Akume-aligned APC stakeholders and other influential figures become openly involved in an opposition-backed effort to challenge Alia. If this happens, the PDP could benefit from a broader coalition of political forces than it would ordinarily command on its own.
Can Alia and Akume Afford to Keep Fighting?
Ultimately, the unfolding situation presents a difficult political dilemma for both Alia and Akume. For Alia, the challenge is to demonstrate that he can consolidate his leadership without alienating influential stakeholders whose political networks remain important to the APC’s electoral success.
His insistence that his political legitimacy comes from the electorate rather than the approval of political godfathers may resonate with voters who oppose excessive political patronage. But the practical demands of party politics require a degree of accommodation, negotiation and coalition-building.
For Akume, the challenge is equally delicate. His political influence in Benue is substantial, but the extent to which he is prepared to deploy that influence against the governor remains an important unanswered question. His association with the strategic alliance, as noted by the governor’s campaign council, has intensified speculation about his political intentions. Yet supporting Tinubu through an independent platform is not necessarily the same as openly campaigning against Alia.
There is also a larger question about President Tinubu’s political interest in the state. A divided APC in Benue could complicate the President’s re-election calculations, especially if rival mobilisation structures continue to compete rather than complement one another.
Against the backdrop of all these variables, the battle for Benue in 2027, while still taking shape, can clearly be distilled into two distinct fronts: the contest between the APC and the PDP, on the one hand, and, on the other hand, the internal struggle between Alia and Akume over who controls the political future of the ruling party.
The irony in al this is that the APC may ultimately lose Benue not necessarily because the PDP has become overwhelmingly stronger, but because the ruling party could become too divided to defend the political advantage it already possesses. Whether that possibility becomes reality will depend largely on what Alia and Akume do next.


