BY LANRE OGUNDIPE
NIGERIA’s 2027 presidential contest is increasingly being fought on two fronts: the political arena and the courtroom. The crisis surrounding former Vice President Atiku Abubakar and the African Democratic Congress (ADC) has brought into sharp focus the intersection of judicial intervention, internal party warfare, electoral administration and the opposition’s continuing struggle to build a credible alternative to the ruling party.
What began as a dispute over the ADC leadership has become a potentially decisive test of Atiku’s presidential ambition and the credibility of opposition coalition-building.
The ADC argues that Atiku was not individually named in the operative orders and that the court did not specifically direct INEC to remove his name from the candidates’ list. That argument deserves consideration, because a judgment must be interpreted through its findings, reasoning and actual orders, not political speculation.
The November 5, 2026 judgment of the Federal High Court in Abuja, delivered by Justice Peter Lifu, has intensified the crisis. Its implications extend beyond the immediate contestants in the leadership dispute to the nomination process that produced Atiku as the ADC presidential candidate.
ALSO READ: ASUU Heroes Day, 2027 Elections And The Futuristic State Police; By Owei Lakemfa
The central question is whether the party can preserve its electoral platform, whether Atiku’s nomination can survive the judgment and whether opposition leaders can prevent their internal disagreements from weakening their challenge to President Bola Tinubu.
The Courtroom Battle
The dispute arose from disagreements over the leadership transition involving former Senate President David Mark and former Osun State Governor Rauf Aregbesola. Nafiu Bala Gombe, a former Deputy National Chairman of the ADC, challenged the legitimacy of the arrangement, raising questions about the alleged resignation of former chairman Ralph Nwosu and the process through which the Mark-led leadership assumed control.
An earlier judgment delivered by Justice Musa Liman on July 2, 2026, in a separate suit instituted by Leke Abejide, had upheld the legality of the handover arrangement. The court also held that Abejide lacked the necessary standing, had not exhausted the party’s internal dispute resolution process and that the suit was not justiciable.
That decision is relevant, but it does not automatically dispose of the separate questions raised in Gombe’s action. The relationship between the two proceedings must be determined by examining their parties, claims, issues and operative orders.
In his November 5 judgment, Justice Lifu reportedly rejected a resignation letter attributed to Gombe, citing material differences between its signature and those on his sworn statements. The court also held that the emergence of Mark and Aregbesola at the ADC’s 99th National Executive Committee meeting on July 27, 2025, had not satisfied the applicable statutory requirement for democratic election.
ALSO READ: We Saw June 12; God, Let’s Not See Another; By Hassan Gimba
The reported orders restrained Mark and Aregbesola from continuing to present themselves as occupants of the disputed offices, directed INEC not to recognise the disputed NEC meeting and set aside decisions taken by the Mark-led executive.
This is where Atiku’s difficulty becomes acute. The consequences reportedly extend to the nomination process conducted under that leadership, including the process that produced him as presidential candidate.
The ADC argues that Atiku was not individually named in the operative orders and that the court did not specifically direct INEC to remove his name from the candidates’ list. That argument deserves consideration, because a judgment must be interpreted through its findings, reasoning and actual orders, not political speculation.
However, the absence of Atiku’s name does not, by itself, preserve a nomination derived from decisions the court has invalidated. The party must demonstrate that the nomination has an independent legal foundation capable of surviving the judgment.
It would therefore be premature to declare Atiku’s electoral fate finally settled. But it would be equally misleading to suggest that his candidacy is unaffected.
ALSO READ: Election-Related Risks And The Future Of Nigerian Democracy; By Jibrin Ibrahim
The ADC’s Legal Defences
The party’s appeal rests on arguments that the appellate court must examine carefully.
First is the effect of the judgment on Atiku’s nomination. The ADC maintains that he was not expressly named in the orders. Its challenge, however, must go beyond that point and establish whether the nomination can stand independently of the disputed leadership arrangement.
Second is the relationship between the July 2 Liman judgment and the November 5 decision. The ADC can argue that courts of coordinate jurisdiction should not produce conflicting decisions on substantially identical issues. But it must establish that the parties, claims and questions in the two proceedings are sufficiently connected to support that contention. Two judgments concerning the same party are not necessarily contradictory.
Third is the Court of Appeal’s preservative order of March 12, 2026. Its significance depends on its precise terms, the parties bound by it and the subject matter it was intended to protect. A preservative order does not automatically validate a disputed leadership structure, nor can its relevance be dismissed without examining its language.
Fourth is the argument that internal party affairs are generally non-justiciable. Political parties enjoy autonomy, but that autonomy is not absolute. Courts may intervene where enforceable rights, statutory obligations or legally prescribed procedures are allegedly breached.
ALSO READ: Iyayi: Remembering The Revolutionary Intellectual Who Lived, Taught And Died In The Service Of The People; By Omotoye Olorode
These are legitimate issues for appellate determination. They are not guarantees of success. The outcome must depend on the record, the applicable law and the reasoning of the appellate court.
The Electoral Act and the Deadline Question
The crisis is complicated by the transition from the Electoral Act 2022 to the Electoral Act 2026.
The disputed leadership transition occurred in July 2025, when the 2022 Act was in force. The subsequent nomination and timetable for the 2027 election fall under the 2026 legislation.
Section 29 of the new Act provides for submission of candidates’ particulars not later than 120 days before the election. Section 31 regulates withdrawal, while Section 33 restricts substitution to the circumstances of a candidate’s death or withdrawal. Where either occurs, the party must conduct another primary and submit a replacement within 14 days.
A separate judgment in a suit instituted by the Youth Party also ruled against INEC imposing deadlines shorter than those prescribed by the Electoral Act 2026. This reinforces an important principle: the Commission’s administrative timetable cannot override statutory provisions.
The more difficult question is whether a court’s invalidation of a party leadership arrangement and decisions taken under it can justify a fresh primary or replacement of a candidate. Section 33 does not expressly identify the invalidation of a party leadership structure or nomination process as an additional ground for substitution.
ALSO READ: Pension Reform In Nigeria: The High Human Cost Of States’ Failure To Deliver; By Ivo Takor
That question requires judicial interpretation. The ADC cannot assume that a fresh primary is automatically available, but neither should its impossibility be declared without examining the Act and the relevant court orders.
INEC’s Responsibility
INEC’s position is delicate. The Commission had earlier withdrawn recognition from the contending ADC factions pending resolution of the leadership dispute. Following the November judgment, it indicated that it would obtain the Certified True Copy and seek legal advice before deciding its next course.
That caution is understandable. INEC must act on the actual judgment, not political interpretations of it. But neutrality must be demonstrated through consistent and transparent decisions.
The ADC filed its notice of appeal and application for stay of execution on November 6. Aregbesola also notified the Commission of his appeal and application. An appeal does not automatically suspend the execution of a judgment. Unless a stay or other relevant order is granted, the subsisting judgment remains the starting point for determining the parties’ legal position.
The ballot box must remain the instrument through which Nigerians choose their leaders. But that choice can only command confidence when parties respect their own rules, institutions discharge their responsibilities without fear or favour, and political ambition remains subject to democratic legitimacy.
INEC must neither disregard a binding order nor extend its consequences beyond what the court has actually decided. It must identify the legal authority for every consequential action and apply the same standards to all political parties.
The Opposition’s Changing Political Map
While the legal battle continues, the opposition landscape is becoming more complicated.
INEC’s final list of presidential candidates, published on September 12, 2026, lists Atiku with Rotimi Amaechi under the ADC, Peter Obi with Rabiu Kwankwaso under the Nigeria Democratic Congress (NDC), and Oyo State Governor Seyi Makinde with Lawal Daura under the Allied Peoples Movement (APM).
These are separate platforms, not a single opposition arrangement.
ALSO READ: Why This Culture Of Not Speaking Ill Of The Dead? By Iduh Onah
The Obi-Kwankwaso ticket brings together two politicians with significant constituencies. Obi retains considerable appeal, particularly in the South-East and among sections of younger urban voters. Kwankwaso commands a substantial political following in Kano and parts of the North-West through the Kwankwasiyya network.
Their alliance offers the possibility of wider geographical reach. But political followers are not transferable assets. The willingness of supporters to move with their leaders cannot be assumed.
Makinde’s APM candidacy introduces another variable, particularly in Oyo State and the South-West. Its electoral significance will depend on the party’s organisation, candidates and capacity to translate political visibility into votes. It would be premature to assume that his candidacy will automatically weaken Tinubu or strengthen another opposition platform.
The 2023 election offers useful historical context. Tinubu secured 8,794,726 votes, Atiku 6,984,520, Obi 6,101,533 and Kwankwaso 1,496,687. Adding the votes of the three opposition candidates may suggest the scale of a possible united opposition, but it would be analytically unsound to treat those figures as votes that can simply be transferred to one candidate.
Voters make independent choices. Their decisions in 2027 will be shaped by candidates, party structures, political agreements, campaign programmes, economic conditions and the performance of government.
The six geopolitical zones remain important to the electoral calculation. Atiku’s roots and political relationships in the North-East, Kwankwaso’s strength in Kano, Obi’s support in the South-East, the PDP’s historical networks in parts of the South-South and North-Central, and Tinubu’s established political base in the South-West all form part of the contest.
But no candidate can win merely by inheriting another politician’s support. Section 134 of the Constitution requires not only the highest number of votes but also at least one-quarter of the votes cast in two-thirds of the states and the Federal Capital Territory. A credible national coalition must therefore reach beyond individual strongholds.
Can Atiku Become a Kingmaker?
If the courts ultimately close the door on Atiku’s ambition through the ADC, his political influence may still matter.
He has longstanding relationships, loyal supporters and experience of national electoral contests. An endorsement of the Obi-Kwankwaso ticket could strengthen its national reach, but endorsement alone would not guarantee the transfer of his political constituency.
Any such arrangement would require negotiation over political interests, organisational participation and the willingness of his supporters to accept the alliance. The existing NDC ticket also means that Atiku cannot simply assume that a place is available to him. Obi and Kwankwaso, in turn, cannot assume that Atiku’s supporters will automatically join them.
He may also decide to remain politically independent or support another arrangement. The kingmaker possibility is therefore a political scenario, not an established outcome.
For Tinubu and the APC, opposition fragmentation may offer an advantage. But a divided opposition does not confer an electoral mandate on the ruling party. Nigerians will still judge the administration on the economy, insecurity, employment, public debt, infrastructure and the wider conditions of daily life.
The opposition must equally understand that opposing the incumbent is not, in itself, a programme for governance. Voters deserve credible answers about what an alternative government would do differently.
The Larger Democratic Question
The ADC crisis exposes a recurring weakness in Nigerian party politics: internal disagreements that should be resolved through credible democratic procedures are allowed to mature into national legal and electoral emergencies.
Courts have a legitimate responsibility to protect enforceable rights and statutory obligations. They must not be denied that responsibility simply because a dispute arises within a political party. But political parties must also resist turning the judiciary into a substitute for internal congresses, leadership processes and nomination procedures.
INEC must remain impartial, comply with valid judicial orders and act strictly within its statutory authority.
Atiku’s predicament is politically significant, but the implications of this crisis are much larger than one man’s ambition. It tests the ADC’s commitment to internal democracy, the judiciary’s handling of politically sensitive disputes, INEC’s institutional neutrality and the opposition’s capacity to build a coherent national alternative.
Until the appellate courts determine the outstanding questions, sweeping declarations about Atiku’s final electoral fate would be premature. The immediate legal danger to his nomination, however, is real.
The 2027 election must not become a contest in which political leaders devote more energy to securing their personal survival than presenting a national programme. Nor should the courts become the arena in which the political future of the country is determined by default.
The ballot box must remain the instrument through which Nigerians choose their leaders. But that choice can only command confidence when parties respect their own rules, institutions discharge their responsibilities without fear or favour, and political ambition remains subject to democratic legitimacy.
That is the real dilemma confronting Atiku, the ADC and Nigeria’s opposition.
Ogundipe, public affairs analyst and former President Nigeria and Africa Union of Journalists, writes this column every Monday.


